America East Conference:
- All-America East First Team
- Gaby Dorsey (2017 New Hampshire)
- All-Rookie Team
- Gaby Dorsey (2015 New Hampshire)
- Rookie of the Week:
- Gaby Dorsey (2015 New Hampshire)
Big 12 Conference Honors:
- All-Big 12 Conference:
- Jen Wandt (2020 and 2018 Second Team - Baylor)
- Dana Larsen (2012 Second Team - Baylor)
- Big-12 All-FreshmenTeam:
- Jen Wandt (2017 - Baylor)
- Michela Ongaro (2013 - Oklahoma State)
- Academic All-Big 12:
- Jen Wandt (2019 Second Team, 2018 First Team - Baylor)
- Michela Ongaro (2015 First Team - Oklahoma State)
- Dana Larsen (2010, 2011, 2012 First Team - Baylor)
- Big 12 Championship Offensive MVP
- Dana Larsen (2012 - Baylor)
- Big 12 Tournament Team
- Dana Larsen (2012 - Baylor)
- Big 12 Soccer Scholar Athlete of the Year
- Dana Larsen (2012 - Baylor)
- Big 12 Defensive Player of the Week
- Jen Wandt (2019 - Baylor)
Missouri Valley Conference Honors:
- Missouri Valley Conference Player of the Year
- Kate Del Fava (2019 - Illinois State)
- All-Missouri Valley Conference:
- Eiley Henderson (2024 All Freshman Team) - Illinois State
- Amelia Crabtree (2023 First Team) - Drake
- Nicole Norfolk (2023 First Team, 2022 First Team, 2021 Second Team) - Valparaiso
- Kate Del Fava (2019 First Team, 2018 First Team - Illinois State)
- Mariah Vichich (2015 First Team, 2013 Second Team - Loyola)
- Monica Gonyo (2014 Second Team - Loyola)
- Valerie Gonyo (2014 Second Team - Loyola)
- Monica Gonyo (2013 Honorable Mention - Loyola)
- Missouri Valley All-Freshman Team
- Nicole Norfolk (2019 - Valparaiso)
- Kate Del Fava (2016 - Illinois State)
- Goalkeeper of the Week
- Monica Gonyo (2013 multiple times, 2014 - Loyola)
- Defensive Player of the Week
- Kate Del Fava (2017 - Illinois State)
- Mariah Vichich (2015 - Loyola)
- Offensive Player of the Week
- Kate Del Fava (2019 - Illinois State) - 4 times
- Loyola Athlete of the Month
Horizon League Honors:
- All-Horizon League:
- Erin Corrigan (2018 Second Team)
- Cassidy Blanchard (2017 First Team, 2015 First Team - UW Milwaukee)
- Valerie Gonyo (2012 Second Team - Loyola)
- Valerie Gonyo (2011 All Newcomer Team - Loyola)
- All-Newcomer Team:
- Taylor Tabbert (2017 - UW Milwaukee)
- Cassidy Blanchard (2014 - UW Milwaukee)
- Mariah Vichich (2012 - Loyola)
- Defensive Player of the Year
- Cassidy Blanchard (2015 - UW Milwaukee)
- Defensive Player of the Week
- Monica Gonyo (2012 - Loyola)
Atlantic Sun:
Summit League:
- Offensive Player of the Week
- Jamie Karch (2013 - South Dakota)
Mid-American Conference:
- Academic All-MAC:
- Jackie Wandt (2014, 2015 - Northern Illinois)
NEWMAC:
- Defensive Player of the Year
- Lauren Davis (2024 - MIT)
- Defensive Player of the Week
- Lilly Mueller (2017 - MIT)
- Academic All Conference
- Lilly Mueller (2016, 2018 - MIT)
PAC-12:
- All-Freshman Team:
- Elyse Bennett (2017 - Washington State)
- Academic All Conference
- Elyse Bennett (2018 - Washington State)
- Academic Honor Roll
- Elyse Bennett (2019 - Washington State)
Midwest Conference:
- Defensive Player of the Year:
- Maya Alberts (2024 - Lawrence University)
- All Conference:
- Maya Alberts (2024 First Team) - Lawrence University
Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference (NAAC):
- Aleah Reesman (2024 All Conference Second Team) - St. Norbert
Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (WIAC):
- Jasmine Wilson (2024 All Conference Honorable Mention) - Whitewater